| What decides the network a device joins | The one password | The device’s MAC address, looked up by a RADIUS server | The key the user enters | The user’s or device’s own credential: a username and password or a certificate |
| Keys | One for everyone | One per device or group, tied to registered MAC addresses | One per room, user or group, generated by the platform | No shared key, an identity per user or device |
| Devices that cannot use 802.1X (consoles, smart TVs, printers) | Work | Work, once their MAC is registered | Work | Do not work, they need a separate SSID or MAC authentication |
| Phones and laptops with private, randomized MAC addresses | Work | Break until the new address is registered | Work: the key, not the address, identifies the group | Work |
| Separation between users | None, everyone shares one network | Per group or device, where the controller enforces it | Per room, user or group: a private network inside the shared SSID | Per policy, such as VLAN or role |
| Changing a key | Every device in the building reconnects | Per device or group | Only that group’s devices reconnect | Per user, no shared key to change |
| Onboarding effort | Hand out one password | Collect and register MAC addresses first | Hand out a key or a QR code | Configure each device or push a profile |
| Typical fit | Small sites with no need to separate users | Known fleets of IoT and headless devices | Residence halls, apartments, senior living, co-working | Managed corporate devices, eduroam |